What is the AfD calling for in its motion?
The motion is titled“Stop Immigration into the Social Welfare System and the Abuse of Social Benefits.” In it, the AfD calls on the federal government to introduce a new law.
This law is intended to significantly restrict foreign nationals' access to social benefits such as the basic income. At the same time, it is intended to give authorities more tools to detect false information and potential abuse of social benefits.
The proposal also includes provisions that could affect all recipients of the citizen's income. These include, for example, a requirement to perform community service for individuals who have been receiving the citizen's income for an extended period of time.
The motion contains a total of six demands. We have summarized the most important points.
The federal government plans to stop providing certain refugees from Ukraine with basic income or welfare benefits in the future. Instead, they are to receive benefits under the Asylum Seekers Benefits Act. The regulation is actually scheduled to take effect on July 1, 2026. However, the...
Stricter Requirements for the Basic Income
The party’s proposals regarding the citizen’s income for foreign nationals are particularly far-reaching. The party wants to generally exclude adults of working age from EU member states and third countries from receiving the citizen’s income. They would only be eligible for benefits if they meet several requirements.
Under the AfD’s plans, third-country nationals would only be eligible for a basic income if they have worked for at least ten years in a job subject to social security contributions and have supported themselves financially. In addition, they must demonstrate German language proficiency at the B2 level and hold a Settlement permit .
For citizens from other EU countries, the AfD requires at least five years of employment subject to social security contributions with an income sufficient to cover basic living expenses. They, too, must demonstrate German language proficiency at the B2 level.
In addition, the AfD wants to limit the duration of basic income benefits for foreign nationals. Adults who are able to work would be eligible to receive basic income for a maximum of twelve consecutive months.
According to the AfD’s plans, receipt of the basic income is to be limited to a total of five years over the course of one’s working life. Those who are no longer eligible after that time are, in principle, to receive only limited transitional benefits and assistance for returning to their country of origin.
Inspection of Cell Phones After Travel to the Country of Origin
Another requirement concerns travel to the country of origin. It applies primarily to individuals with a humanitarian Residence permit.
If there is concrete evidence that a person has traveled to their country of origin without Foreigners' office this Foreigners' office the Foreigners' office , the Federal Police should be authorized to inspect digital devices such as cell phones. The data collected should enable the authorities to determine, among other things, the person’s identity, origin, travel route, places visited, and the purpose of the trip.
The results are to be made available to the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF), the relevant immigration or asylum authorities, and, under certain conditions, also to the Jobcenter.
The AfD justifies its demand by arguing that travel to the country of origin is important both for maintaining refugee status and for receiving social benefits.
Basic Income Provided via a Debit Card in Certain Cases
The AfD wants to pay out the basic income via a prepaid card in certain cases. This would apply, for example, in cases of failure to fulfill obligations or when there is concrete suspicion of benefit fraud.
The payment card is intended to allow government agencies to limit cash withdrawals and international money transfers. However, the AfD does not call for the widespread use of the payment card for all recipients of the citizen's income in its motion.
Fewer Benefits for Asylum Seekers
The AfD also wants to amend the Asylum Seekers Benefits Act. During the asylum proceedings and after an asylum application has been denied, those affected would, in principle, receive only essential benefits until their departure. These include, for example, housing, food, clothing, and hygiene products.
Cash benefits available without conditions should be limited to a minimum. Medical care should also be significantly restricted. In principle, it should cover only emergencies and absolutely necessary treatments on a case-by-case basis.
In addition, the AfD wants to abolish the so-called “analog benefits” under Section 2 of the Asylum Seekers Benefits Act (AsylbLG). As a result, even after a prolonged stay in Germany, those affected would no longer receive higher benefits based on social assistance. Instead, permanently lower benefits under the Asylum Seekers Benefits Act would apply.
Child benefits for children living in other EU countries are to be reduced
The AfD is also calling for adjustments to child benefits for children living in another EU country. If the cost of living there is lower than in Germany, the child benefits should also be lower.
The amount should be based on the cost of living in the child’s country of residence. The authorities should also conduct more thorough checks to determine where a child actually lives, whether child support is being paid, and whether the child is attending school or pursuing vocational training.
A recent court ruling shows that a Settlement permit not always Settlement permit proof of sufficient means of support. In special cases—such as serious illness or the need to care for a family member—an exception may be granted. But when exactly does this apply?...
Conclusion: What happens now?
Important: The proposed measures are currently only policy demands put forward by the AfD. The motion will be debated in the Bundestag today. However, this will not change the laws currently in effect.
For the legal situation to change, the following would have to happen:
- The Bundestag would have to approve the AfD's motion.
- Under those provisions, the federal government would be called upon (but not required) to draft a bill and submit it to the Bundestag and the Bundesrat.
- The Bundestag, the Bundesrat, and the relevant committees would have to deliberate on the proposed bill.
- The Bundestag and Bundesrat would have to pass the bill following deliberations.
- Only after the Bundestag and the Bundesrat pass the bill by a majority vote could the rules demanded by the AfD take effect.
Since some of the proposed measures could also entail amendments to the Basic Law, EU law, and data protection regulations, it is considered unlikely that the Bundestag will ultimately adopt the AfD’s motion.