Various cookies are used on our website: technical cookies, cookies for marketing purposes and cookies for analysis purposes; in principle, you can also visit our website without cookies being set. This does not apply to technically necessary cookies. You can view and change the current settings at any time by clicking on the fingerprint that appears (bottom left). You have the right to withdraw your consent at any time. Further information can be found in our privacy policy under Cookies. By clicking on "Accept all", you agree that we may set the aforementioned cookies for marketing and analysis purposes.

The picture shows a young couple working together on forms. Is Naturalization coming soon despite citizen's income? A proposal is currently before the Bundestag to allow Naturalization regardless of income.

Left wants to enable Naturalization without proof of income

While the German government is discussing tougher asylum and migration laws - including the abolition of so-called Naturalization after three years and the planned two-year suspension of family reunification for those entitled to subsidiary protection - the opposition parliamentary group Die Linke is taking a different approach.
Written by:
Expertly reviewed by:
Christin Schneider
Expert for Immigration law

Share:

With two motions in the Bundestag, it wants to counterbalance the policies of the governing CDU/CSU and SPD parties. Among other things, the focus is on a proposal to decouple Naturalization in Germany from income. The corresponding motion will be debated in the Bundestag on Friday, 27 June 2025.

Facilitated Naturalization: What is the left demanding?

The text of the application is not yet publicly available. Little is therefore known. The website of the German Bundestag only states that the motion will be discussed on Friday and: "In it, the parliamentary group calls for naturalization to be made possible regardless of income."

In concrete terms, this could mean that the party wants to remove the requirement of independent means of subsistence from the citizenship law. Until now, this has been one of the main hurdles for migrants on the path to German citizenship.

If the proposal were implemented, people who receive citizens' income or other social benefits could also be naturalized in the future - provided they meet all other legal requirements for Naturalization .

Detailed information on the content and justification of the Left Party's motion is expected during the Bundestag session on Friday.

Our recommended reading
http://Lebensunterhalt%20und%20Einbürgerung%20-%20Voraussetzungen%20und%20Tipps%20zur%20Hilfe
Livelihood and Naturalization - Requirements and tips for help

A central aspect of Naturalization in Germany is securing your livelihood. This means that you must be able to provide for yourself and your family without state support, except for certain unproblematic social benefits....

Facilitate family reunification, not suspend it

In addition to the naturalization issue , Die Linke is also bringing a second motion into the debate: This is directed against the planned suspension of family reunification for persons entitled to subsidiary protection. Instead of tightening restrictions, the parliamentary group is calling for existing regulations to be eased and family reunification for humanitarian reasons to be strengthened.

Naturalization 2025: These requirements apply

Anyone wishing to apply for German citizenship in 2025 must generally meet the following requirements:

  • At least five years of legal residence in Germany
  • German language skills at level B1 (proven by language certificate or school-leaving certificate)
  • Commitment to the free and democratic basic order
  • Passed naturalization test on history, politics and society (or alternatively: a German educational or school-leaving qualification)
  • No serious offenses (max. 90 daily rates)
  • valid national passport and further proof of identity and citizenship
  • secure residence in Germany
  • Independent means of subsistence (without receiving citizen's allowance, ALG II, etc.)

The current federal government (CDU/CSU and SPD) wants to abolish the Naturalization naturalization introduced in 2024 - i.e. the right to Naturalization after just three years in the case of particularly good integration. This will also be discussed in the Bundestag on Friday, 27 June 2025.

Our recommended reading
couple with german passport in front of reichstag
German Naturalization: Requirements and special features

In order to be naturalized in Germany, you must meet various requirements. You can find out what these are here...

What does "independent means of subsistence" mean in concrete terms?

A key criterion for Naturalization is that applicants must be able to support themselves without basic state benefits (such as citizens' income support or social assistance). This means that the person must earn enough money themselves - either through work or other income (self-employment).

On the other hand, government benefits such as

  • Child benefit
  • Pension for basic security in old age and
  • Reduced earning capacity
  • Child and youth welfare services in accordance with Book Eight of the German Social Code
  • Pensions from social insurance
  • Parental allowance
  • BAföG
  • Housing benefit
  • Sickness benefit
  • Unemployment benefit (ALG I)
  • Training assistance and benefits under the Long-Term Care Insurance Act

off. Anyone who only receives such benefits can still apply for a German passport.

How high must the income be for Naturalization ?

There is no fixed minimum income threshold for Naturalization in Germany. The decisive factor is whether applicants can cover all their expenses (and possibly those of their family) without basic security benefits. This includes

  • Rent and ancillary costs
  • Health insurance
  • Food, clothing, electricity
  • Maintenance payments, if applicable

As a rule of thumb: if you are single, you must be ableto prove that you have amonthly income above the citizen's allowance rate and additional housing costs - this currently corresponds to around 1,500 euros gross per month. However, this minimum income is gradually increased the more family members are part of the household.

Exceptions are possible in certain cases - for example, if the spouse provides all or most of the family income.

Our recommended reading
calculation of the incorporation costs
Naturalization costs: overview and savings tips

Costs are incurred for Naturalization . But how high are they and how are they made up? Find out more...

Conclusion: Does the Left's motion have a chance in the Bundestag?

Our assessment: It is rather unlikely that the Left Party's motion will find a majority in the Bundestag. The demand to allow Naturalization regardless of income contradicts the current migration policy of the federal government - especially the governing parties CDU/CSU and SPD. No support is to be expected from the AfD either.

There are likely to be individual supporters within the Greens, particularly from an integration and social policy perspective. However, a parliamentary majority for this initiative does not appear realistic at present.

More information on the Left Party's motion and the planned amendments to the law - including the two-year suspension of family reunification for persons entitled to subsidiary protection and the abolition of Naturalization - will be provided during the Bundestag debate on Friday, 27 June 2025.

Do you have any questions?
Are you experiencing difficulties with the naturalization process and still have questions? Contact us and our legal experts will be happy to help you with any question!
anna profile picture
Anna Faustmann
Editor
Anna Faustmann is an editor at Migrando . With her sound education and many years of experience in journalism and digital marketing, she brings a deep understanding of the conception and creation of ...