Background: Fraudulent language certificates
The motion was triggered by cases of forged language and integration certificates that became public in late summer 2025. Research by RTL and Stern showed that providers on TikTok or Instagram were posing as language schools and selling forged certificates. Certificates ranging from A1 to C2 were offered, as well as certificates for the "Living in Germany" test – some for several hundred to 1,500 euros.
The AfD's motion is entitled"Preventing organized fraud in the naturalization process"and comprises five key measures.
The "Living in Germany" test (naturalization test) serves as proof of knowledge of the legal and social order and living conditions in Germany. All information about the test, such as costs, procedure and duration as well as the 300 questions and answers can be found here. Contents...
1. Halt to Naturalization the granting of residence permits
A key point of the AfD motion is the demand for a temporary halt to all naturalizations and the granting of residence permits. The only exceptions are asylum procedures and regular labor migration.
According to the AfD, this suspension should remain in place until a "fraud-proof procedure" for verifying language and integration certificates has been developed. This is intended to reduce the risk of abuse. Ongoing procedures should only be continued once stricter rules are in place.
2. Strict examination of language and integration certificates
The AfD also calls for a nationwide, uniform, and forgery-proof system for issuing and checking language and integration course certificates. This new procedure is to be developed jointly by the federal government, the states, and the examination centers.
According to the AfD, there should be a central register in which all certificates are recorded and can be clearly assigned to a specific person. Authorities should be able to check these entries automatically.
The AfD criticizes the fact that many certificates are currently only available in paper form and could easily be forged. A digital register is intended to reliably confirm authenticity, date of issue, and place of examination.
3. Establishment of a nationwide task force
Another component of the proposal is the establishment of a nationwide task force. Its purpose is to assess the extent of possible fraud cases and centrally document ongoing investigations.
In addition, the task force is to take action against the trade in forged certificates and the sale of exam questions on social media platforms. From the AfD's point of view, there is currently no Germany-wide structure in place to investigate this phenomenon.
4. Re-examination of all naturalizations and Residence permit
The AfD also demands that all naturalizations and Residence permit granted since the beginning of 2024 be reviewed. This review is to take place nationwide and be organized in cooperation with the federal states.
According to the AfD, the authorities should systematically check whether forged language certificates, false information, or missing requirements have gone unnoticed in the procedures.
If such a review reveals that naturalizations or Residence permit were Residence permit granted, they should be revoked in accordance with existing laws.
Background: According to Section 35 of the German Nationality Act (StAG), Naturalization can be Naturalization if it was obtained through deception, threats, or bribery, or if important requirements were not met. In the case of residence permits, Section 51(1)(3) of the Residence Act allows for the revocation of the permit if it was obtained through false or incomplete information.
5. Social media screening for naturalization
As a fifth measure, the AfD demands that naturalization authorities be required to checkapplicants' social media activities. From the party's point of view, this would allow any extremist, anti-Semitic, or anti-constitutional attitudes to be identified at an early stage—before Naturalization .
The AfD justifies this by arguing that personal conversations at the agency or written declarations on the free democratic basic order are, in their opinion, often just "lip service"—statements that sound good to the outside world but are not meant sincerely.
Before applying for Naturalization , the question of income arises for many interested parties. Is there a precise requirement and what exactly do you have to pay attention to when providing information? This blog article gives you an overview of which criteria are important when it comes to income and why the amount of...
Parties in the Bundestag oppose motion
The AfD's motion was discussed for the first time in the Bundestag on Wednesday (December 3, 2025) and was met with clear rejection by all other parliamentary groups.
The CDU/CSU strongly rejected the motion. Dr. Cornell-Anette Babendererde accused the AfD of using "hate and incitement" and of submitting a motion even though the federal government had already responded to the known cases of fraud.
She announced her own draft bill, which would allow for a ban of up to ten years on Naturalization in cases of proven fraud. However, Babendererde said that individual cases of fraud were no reason to halt all naturalizations and Residence permit nationwide.
Alliance 90/The Greens also clearly rejected the motion. Lamya Kaddor said that the AfD was artificially inflating individual cases in order to generate mistrust toward naturalized citizens. Migration is important for the economy and society, she said, and a strict immigration ban would have serious consequences.
On behalf of the SPD, Hakan Demir stated that naturalization is an important part of a modern immigration society. He rejected the impression of "massive fraud" and referred to figures from Thuringia, Saxony, and Berlin, which confirm only a few cases. According to Demir, the existing security checks are working well.
The Left Party also spoke out clearly against the motion. Luigi Pantisano emphasized that most naturalized citizens have been living, working, paying taxes, and being part of society in Germany for many years. In his view, the AfD wants to make naturalization more difficult in principle and unsettle people.
Can Naturalization be suspended Naturalization ?
A look at the law also shows that no, it is not possible to completely halt all naturalizations. There is no rule in the Nationality Act that allows for the blanket suspension of all current or future procedures. The authorities must examine each application individually and decide whether Naturalization a right to Naturalization according to the existing rules.
A blanket ban—i.e., without individual case reviews—would also violate important provisions of the Basic Law, such as the equal treatment of all people and the principle of proportionality. This is because even people who meet all the requirements would be affected.
In addition, the state may not halt ongoing and lawful proceedings without a clear legal reason. Even if the Bundestag were to decide on a moratorium, it is uncertain whether the Federal Constitutional Court would allow this. A complete halt to naturalization would therefore be legally impossible and practically unfeasible.
Another problem would be the AfD's demand for a review of all naturalizations and Residence permit 2024. Many naturalization authorities are already severely overburdened. Reviewing all decisions would require a great deal of time and personnel and is hardly feasible in the current situation.
Conclusion
The AfD's motion has sparked a major debate in the Bundestag about fraud in the naturalization process. However, all other parliamentary groups clearly reject the proposal.
The AfD warns of a "loss of control" and calls for the procedures to be temporarily suspended. The other parties, on the other hand, emphasize that strict checks are already in place and that a few cases of fraud are no reason to completely halt Naturalization. Furthermore, such a moratorium would be very difficult to enforce legally and could violate the Basic Law.
The motion will now be further discussed in the Interior Committee and later debated again in the Bundestag. However, as things stand at present, it is very unlikely that it will receive majority support.