First things first: there are currently no political plans to tighten the requirements for Naturalization . With the exception of Naturalization naturalization, which is likely to be abolished in the coming weeks, the requirements for a German passport - as set out in Section 10 StAG - will continue to apply.
Political reactions and demands
Since the fraud involving fake language certificates came to light, there have been repeated calls for stricter controls. For example, representatives of the police union are calling for all procedures that require a B1 certificate or "Living in Germany" test to be temporarily suspended.
The AfD is also calling for a halt to naturalizations and residence permits until a "fraud-proof control practice" is in place. The party is also calling for a comprehensive review of citizenships that have already been granted. The CDU has expressed similar views - they are also calling for a new review of all Residence permit and naturalizations already granted.
Are the requirements for Naturalization becoming stricter?
In short - no.
A tightening of the requirements for Naturalization is currently not in sight. Nevertheless, the question arises: How easy is it to tighten the requirements and control measures for Naturalization ?
The decisive factor here is the distinction between:
- Measures that can be implemented by the administration immediately and without changing the law
- Measures that require an amendment to the Citizenship Act (StAG)
What measures can the administration implement - without changing the law
- Stricter verification of the authenticity of certificates
- Increased random checks
- Mandatory digital/verifiable evidence
- Audit of inspection bodies
- Queries or checks in case of doubt
- Personal language tests on suspicion of forgery
Many of these measures are the responsibility of the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF), the Ministry of the Interior and the local naturalization authorities. They can be tightened up as part of the naturalization process through guidelines, application instructions or stricter admission procedures. No change to the law is required for these adjustments.
What can only be legally changed by law
Fundamental changes - such as an increase in the required language level or an extension of the minimum residence period - require an amendment to the Citizenship Act (StAG) and must be passed by the Bundestag and Bundesrat. This is politically and parliamentarily complex.
There are currently no draft laws or initiatives aimed at tightening naturalization requirements. The only exception is the planned abolition of Naturalization naturalization.
Requirements for Naturalization in Germany
According to § 10 StAG, foreign nationals in Germany are entitled to Naturalization if they:
- have been living legally in Germany for at least five years
- an unlimited right of residence (Settlement permit) or a Residence permit which is approved for Naturalization
- secure their livelihood independently and without state aid
- have not committed any serious criminal offenses
- have sufficient knowledge of German (at least B1)
- pass the "Living in Germany" naturalization test
- can prove their identity and nationality
- recognize the free and democratic basic order
These standards were only reformed in 2024. At that time, the regular residence period was reduced from eight to five years. At the same time, the option of dual citizenship was introduced.
Before applying for Naturalization , the question of income arises for many interested parties. Is there a precise requirement and what exactly do you have to pay attention to when providing information? This blog article gives you an overview of which criteria are important when it comes to income and why the amount of...
Which conditions could be tightened - and how?
Duration of residence
The shortening of the naturalization period from eight to five years was only decided in 2024 in the reform of citizenship law. A further extension would require an amendment to the Citizenship Act. This would require a draft bill and the approval of the Bundestag and Bundesrat.
Language skills
The statutory threshold is level B1 of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR). An increase to B2 or C1 would also only be possible by amending the law.
However, the administration and the BAMF could immediately set stricter standards for the verification and recognition of certificates - for example, only allowing certain verification bodies or ordering a personal interview if there are doubts about the authenticity of a certificate.
Naturalization test "Living in Germany"
Section 10 (1) no. 6 StAG stipulates that "knowledge of the legal and social order and living conditions in Germany" must be demonstrated for Naturalization . The naturalization test "Living in Germany" (LiD) is required for this. Exceptions apply, for example, in the case of a German school-leaving certificate.
The BAMF determines the exact content, exam questions and pass thresholds of the LiD. Within this framework, the office could increase the pass mark, make the questions more difficult or order additional oral examinations. A change in the law would not be necessary.
But the same applies here: We are not currently aware of any plans for such adjustments.
Livelihood and exemption from punishment
According to § 10 StAG, Naturalization is only possible if the applicant is able to support themselves independently. In addition, Naturalization is excluded in the case of serious criminal offences - specifically convictions of more than 90 daily rates.
Both requirements are stipulated by law.
More stringent measures - such as longer retention periods after a conviction - would only be possible by amending the Citizenship Act.
Residence permit
For Naturalization in accordance with Section 10 (1) No. 2 StAG, a person must have a permanent right of residence or a residence permit approved for Naturalization . This is a legal requirement, not merely an administrative practice. An amendment to the law is therefore also needed to tighten up this requirement.
Revocation of citizenship in the event of fraud
A central point of the current debate is the possibility of subsequently revoking a German passport. According to Section 35 StAG, citizenship can be revoked if it was obtained by deception or forged documents.
In principle, a German passport can be revoked up to ten years after it has been issued if it was obtained under false pretenses, for example through forged documents.
Conclusion
The forged certificates have triggered a debate about the requirements for Naturalization . Many of the demands are currently focused on stricter controls of the certificates and the re-examination of already completed procedures.
However, a look at the requirements for Naturalization in Germany - such as a secure livelihood or a minimum stay of five years - shows that a fundamental tightening of the conditions would in most cases require a change in the law, which would have to be approved by the Bundestag and Bundesrat. No such changes are currently planned.
In the short term, however, the administration and BAMF can take a much stricter approach to checking certificates and proof in order to prevent fraud.